Home » Ad-alysis, Featured, Fresh from market

Jaguar’s decline and possible resurrection

2 January 2010 4,515 views 13 Comments

Stories of declining brands abound, more so in a brand-driven market like the luxury car segment. And Jaguar which was once synonymous with sophistication and style finds its brand image eroded while competitors thrive.

So where did they go wrong? When Ford bought Jaguar in 1989, the ‘Big Cat’ was perceived to be low on reliability but their designs were admired. The powers-that-be at Ford thought they had their task cut out. Funding was flooded into the engineering department and phrases like ‘British engineering’ and ‘the art of performance’ were communicated to the populace. However, experts feel that over the years they did not change their designs and stuck to rather traditional ones while the likes of BMW, Mercedes, Audi and Lexus made their cars more and more stylish and thus began Jaguar’s decline.

Jaguar has been criticized for letting the look of their cars age. Research shows Jaguar buyers are older than the average luxury car shopper. According to George Magliano, director of automotive industry research at Global Insight, Jaguar is suffering from an ageing audience. “I don’t think people under 60 are aware of the luster of the Jaguar brand name”, says Magliano. In the luxury car market where it is important to stand out in terms of design Jaguar has lost out to its German rivals. And this has happened to a brand that was once remembered for revolutionary designs such as the 1960 E-type which was in its time a benchmark for sports car design.

The 2001 S-type and the 2003 XJ typify Jaguar’s old-fashioned design -

2001 XF and 2003 XJ

The design was not the only reason for the decline. Some Jaguars are built on platforms used for Ford cars and several parts in the Jaguar were shared across several brands of Ford. Even though this habit is common in the industry, Jonathan Linkov, Consumer Reports’ managing editor for automobiles, feels that this might have hurt Jaguar’s image and quality. Also, the engines used in the older Jaguar cars were repeated in the newer versions. At the rate at which BMW, Mercedes and Audi dish out new engines, they have probably come up with a few as you are reading this! Their engines are more powerful and more advanced as a result and Jaguar has been left behind.

Being one of Ford’s several brands could be a disadvantage and in Jaguar’s case, it is evident that the brand has not received the focus and funding it needs desperately. But now, under the ownership of Tata, Jaguar is seen as a ‘jewel in the crown’ and that shows. In the middle of 2009, Jaguar came up with a new campaign for its brand, with a new positioning for Jaguar cars – “GORGEOUS”. Take a look at the new advert -

The reason Jaguar can go  for such a bold campaign is that the designs for the next generation Jags (result of Ford’s last efforts to rebuild the brand) have been received exceedingly well. American talk-show host Jay Leno said during the unveiling of the 2010 XJ, “If you say to yourself that this doesn’t look like a Jag… I’m sorry… you’re officially an old guy”.  The pictures tell the tale of an obvious effort to create more modern looking Jags.

2009 XF and 2010 XJWhile Jaguar seems to be getting back on its feet in terms of sales, there’s more good news. Jaguar has topped the 2009 JD Power & Associates Vehicle Dependability Study, beating Lexus. The fact that Jaguar has risen from No.10 in 2008 to No.1 in 2009 shows their engineers have done their part.

With the designers and engineers playing their roles to perfection, the brand’s marketers now face a behemoth challenge. Jaguar was once believed to be poorly built and old fashioned. They must now continue to build the style factor and also communicate the fact that Jags are among the most reliable cars in the world. This, however, is easier said than done. Jaguar’s marketers seem to be on the right track, but they still have a long way to go before they can resurrect the Big Cat’s past glory.

Sam(R. Prashanth Samuel is a PGDM 2011 student at IIM Calcutta. Write to him at prashanths2011@email.iimcal.ac.in)
  • Prashanth Samuel

    @Aayush: Exactly… the brand’s quadruped namesake is a combination of power and beauty and that’s what Jaguar represents as well. We’ll have to watch out for the Jags to be launched in 2010 and their full scale entry into India.

    @Everyone: Here’s some more news I’d missed in the article

    - Back in 2008, the Jaguar XF was awarded the ‘Car of the Year’ by Auto Express. Read more here

    - Taj hotels are using Jags to transport customers (read: potential buyers)

  • Aayush Shrivastava

    @Everyone

    It’s the Big Cat we are talking about. ‘She’ can very well be gorgeous, regal and blood thirsty. When I think of Jaguar, I actually think of a slim, quiet, green eyed tigress.

    @Sam’s last comment: LOL LOL LOL

  • Prashanth Samuel

    @Pavan: Wouldn’t you rather have people see you in/with something ‘gorgeous’?

  • Prashanth Samuel

    And as you said, yes, Ford did begin the effort to rebuild the brand. The reliability ratings and the latest designs were Ford’s doing. But now, under Tata, there is a new buzz around Jaguar and its new campaigns.

  • Prashanth Samuel

    @Prashant Khurana: Yes of course, the credit for the Concept-XF does go to Ford. The designer Ian Callum himself is ex-Ford. But it was rather late, the brand had been sidelined for more than a decade and half, and the sharing of parts did not go well with the buyers. The thing about Tata is that we at least know it’ll be given importance. How they manage costs is a different issue.

  • http://pavanpalety.wordpress.com pavan

    @Harish – I agree with your ‘A suave man’s arm candy’ and ‘alpha male would like to have in his kitty’. But imagine the effect this portrays. It is like that of an exquisite painting that every art collector must have. In other words it gives me a feeling of something thats better left in the garage to be admired rather than meet the challenges on the road. I cannot help but wonder if this image is good for a sports car like jag.

  • Prashanth Samuel

    @pavan’s question: About the engines, Jaguar seem to have learnt its lesson. Take the current XFR, Jaguar’s sports saloon, launched early in 2009 to take on the BMW M5. This Bimmer has been the king of this segment for years and to take it on, the XFR car comes with an all new welsh engine – 5Litre, 510 bhp , similar to the BMW, but against the BMW’s 520Nm torque, the Jag produces 625Nm!!! and it looks fabulous as well.

    As for the ‘gorgeous’ bit, yes, it might be feminine, but while talking about a car I still feel it’ll work well. As Harish said, it’ll be like a man’s dream to have one

  • Prashant Khurana

    Dude, the new vehicles that u talked about were actually designed and engineered under Ford… Its just that Tata’s are getting the benefit of that
    Ford made mistakes where their premium brands were concerned and sought to change that… Only the fuel price rise and the financial crisis put paid to its efforts…. With the result that they’ve almost sold off all their brands and are now focusing only on Ford and their American brands, Mercury and Lincoln

  • Harish Sarma

    @Pavan – Your post did make me think. From what I figured out, if you put the new positining and the ad together, what “Gorgeous” comes to mean according to me is – A suave man’s arm candy. It’s the kind of thing that the alpha male would like to have in his kitty and show the world.
    And that is where as Sam points out I guess – the complement “Gorgeous” fits in so wonderfully. Coming to think of it not many other words in the English lexicon fit the bill so perfectly. And it does have the intended effect it seems going by what Jay Leno has to say.
    Again if the Jag is more of an older folks car – the new positioning would just set in as one more attribute to the already present ones and may not necessitate a deviation.

    ~Would love to hear thoughts on this

  • Pingback: Twitted by shshank

  • http://pavanpalety.wordpress.com pavan

    Congrats sam on the nice article.

    The 2010 jaguar looks stunning.

    Having said that, I do agree with Harish above.
    Gorgeous does have a feminine feel and when it comes to cars that could do a lot of damage, especially to a brand like jaguar. Jaguar is the one of the largest and powerful felines around,compact and well muscled. I doubt ‘gorgeous’ is the word one would associate with it.

    As your article quotes ‘Their(bmw,audi etc) engines are more powerful and more advanced as a result and Jaguar has been left behind.’
    I wonder what they are doing on this front.

  • Prashanth Samuel

    The word ‘gorgeous’ does have a hint of femininity about it. But where cars are concerned, rather than ‘effeminate’, it’ll just give an impression of stunning looks – an image that Jaguar is trying hard to build. The old Jaguar message revolved around performance, while the design took a back seat. Now they are changing that.
    The problem with reliability is that the old Jaguars were perceived to be unreliable. Even though the cars have improved vastly on that front, the old perception still lingers, remember most Jaguar customers are older folk. And to some extent perceptions get inherited by following generations, hence the marketers have the task of changing that as well.

  • Harish Sarma

    Awesome info packed article. Just trying to understand more – will the “Gorgeous” campaign give the Jaguar brand more of an effeminate look and feel? Also how much of a change is it going from the earlier messages to this one? And finally – how does dependability fit into the picture?
    ~Kudos on a great article