Home » Featured, GoD

Anatomy Of A Purchase Part-II

3 November 2010 3,109 views 18 Comments

The backdrop

This article is a follow up to my earlier article in which I talk about my journey to buying a new camera. This post will make much more sense if you have gone through that one though I have tried to keep references to earlier posts to a minimum. Here’s the link: http://www.themarketers.in/?p=2210

Canon_lounge_Ambimall

The learning

Now let us look at the entire story wearing a marketer’s hat. First and foremost, this case epitomizes a consumer’s journey in consumer durables category. So much so that even if I don’t mention the product/category, it shouldn’t take much effort to figure it out.

A major pointer is the duration and effort put in the decision making, also called as Involvement. In a FMCG setup purchases are either done before the need arises (as in the weekly/monthly shopping of detergents and soaps) or done within a short span of time after the need is felt (need for a cold beverage) or are induced by visible merchandise at the

point of purchase. On the contrary, for durables the level of involvement is pretty high, and more often than not includes multiple visits to outlets selling them. Consumers actively seek information from various sources not just about the product features but also comparative information on price, after sales service and delivery options (for bulky items). Generally speaking, involvement is higher for costlier items and technology driven categories like televisions, digital Cameras, mobile phones, computers/laptops etc.

Another peculiar thing about this category is that there were TV ads about other products from the brand but not for DSLRs. I did see a few print ads in newspapers and some photography magazines. But there was a plethora of information available on the web, especially on discussion forums. This is in line with the finding that word-of-mouth is a key influencer to purchase in this category.

A picture is worth a thousand words; an experience worth a million! – Shashank Bajaj (Fellow Marketer)

Product demo is another key factor which pushes a brand from consideration set to purchase basket. And people at Canon realize that and thus have Canon Image Stores, which have various camera models available to be tried out. Though most of dealers will let you play around with the product a bit, but a complete store solely devoted to experience various products along with all possible add-ons (lenses and stuff) is truly revolutionary. Without the pressure of closing the sale, the experience delivered is way superior to the traditional scheme of things.

There are a few consumer perceived risks associated with high a ticket purchase. These are generally categorized as Functional, Financial, Physical, Psychological, Social and Time based. Physical can be understood as risk posed by product to one’s well being e.g. “Is fast food healthy or does it lead to obesity and other problems?” An example of social risk would be: “Will my friends laugh at my pink shirt?” Time based risk deals with the risk of spending time in searching for another product if this one doesn’t work well. Risks evident in this particular case are Functional and Financial. Functional risk refers to the product not performing as expected (e.g. “Will the touch screen of my phone work even after heavy usage?”) and financial risk refers to not getting enough value for money and perception that something cheaper might be available which can serve the same purpose (e.g. “Is there a camera model in the market which offers the same features but at a lower price?”). To deal with financial risk, people generally seek more information as I discussed earlier. To minimize functional risks, people generally prefer brands they have already used before and are satisfied with. That might have been one of the major reasons why I went for Canon over Nikon.

Another noteworthy concept in the narration is that of Cognitive Dissonance, as pointed out by my fellow Marketers and our readers. It is fairly common where products have a lot of feature combinations and consumers generally have to make trade-offs between them. It refers to the uncomfortable feeling post-purchase that a competing brand would have been better. Brands use various means to allay such fears and one of them is to stay in touch with the buyers/consumers and build lasting relationships.

To build relationships with their existing customers, Canon has a website called Canon Edge (http://www.canon.co.in/edge/) which provides their customers with a forum to engage with other Canon owners; showcase and discuss their photographs and hone their skills. A quick tour through the website will tell you why this is a great way of using a Social CRM tool to reduce cognitive dissonance and build loyalty.

If you have survived my theory heavy monologue till now, you deserve recognition. Make this achievement of yours known to the world by leaving a comment :)

Varun(Varun Sharma is a PGDM (2011) student at IIM Calcutta. Write to him at varuns2011@email.iimcal.ac.in).
  • Varun

    @hemant: nice find!!

    @Amway model: I guess the reason Amway does not start selling through retail stores is that currently, their entire distribution network is dependent on ABOs. Opening a retail store might not go down well with ABOs and they simply cannot afford to piss them off! And not because they want to maintain the sanctity of a demo store!
    I can say this with enough confidence because the whole idea, otherwise, is counter-intuitive.
    FMCG is a low involvement category and thus prone to impulse purchases -> thus important to close the deal as soon as the buyer gets interested. So it makes all the sense in the world for a demo which provides demo, to make the sale as well, unless and until there is some other barrier (which in this case I guess is appeasing ABOs)

    @Cameras: At the cost of repeating myself, I would say that impulse purchases in such high involvement categories are very rare. So a decent lead management system would be a great and there is no need to close the deal at demo store. Here maintaining sanctity of the demo concept makes all the sense in the world.
    I guess, entire confusion began when we started evaluating the idea of incentives for generating/managing leads.

  • Paridhi

    @hemant- A nice relevant article about experience stores though I feel that it is more relevant for amway since by making it an experience store only they mean to emphasise that selling happens only through ABO s whereas for canon retail selling is the method of selling. :)

    @nishant- Sure I must have missed it as pointed out by varun we are not aware of the presence or absence of any method of in

  • Nishant Choudhury

    @Paridhi…
    We have already discussed that…the thing about per sale incentive not being there. See my first post.
    Cheers!

  • Hemant

    Hi all

    I see this discussion getting more interesting as many people are joining.

    other day, I was reading Brand equity and I saw “experinece store” topic has been discussed by CEO of Amway in his direct selling model. He said “The retail format is not a point of sale as we don’t want it to cannibalise our core business operation. Customers can try our products at the experience centres and we will help them get in touch with the ABO(Amway Business Owner) in the area they live to buy the products,”

    You can check following link for complete article
    http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/features/brand-equity/Amway-involves-thinking-and-acting-like-an-FMCG-company/articleshow/6935869.cms

    The takeaway is that the concept of experience store is not diluted no matter how important customer is for any company following any business model.

  • Paridhi

    Yes I agree the incentives currently offered are not known . Hence it would be difficult to work out an assumption. The comments book could definitely be some indication of the quality of service offered , though a weak one.

  • Varun

    @Paridhi:
    A sales scenario without sales based variable pay is more or less unheard of…good food for thought. Will try and figure out if there are such successful cases available. For now, consider this:
    We don’t know for sure whether there are any incentives involved for the guys showing people around. They have a feedback/comment book kept there which customers are encouraged to fill up. Maybe, though I doubt it, there is some way in which they are incentivizing those demonstrators based on the comments received in that book.

  • Paridhi

    Excellent discussion with probably all possibilities pointed out with exhaustive list of pro s and cons , but I would still point out that even though the lounge leaves the person with an experience , the experience might not be indelible enough to get the impulsive buyer to follow up and take the pains to contact another dealer and this is where the option of spot purchase would help boost sales . We have not considered the option of not giving incentives to the salesperson for unit sales which will ensure;
    1. the products are not pushed for sale at the customer since there is no extra gain related
    2. the customer can be saved the pain of visiting another store.
    3. the product will not have to face repeated competition with other brands ( nikon , in our case)and risk the loss of a customer since another customer might actually be lured.
    4. since the salesperson at the store at doing a good job without incentives at present , the same can be ensured even for spot sales.
    5. the lounge will then deliver a full experience right from awareness to taking the experience and the product back with you.:)

  • Varun

    @hemant, susrita:
    You guys are bang on target and so is the Canon Image lounge…they give out a long and almost exhaustive list of dealers who stock Canon products along with their address and phone number. But I am still not sold on the idea of a store in the proximity…you know such things have a way of developing liaisons which would encourage people at demo stores to redirect people to this particular store. Just an opinion.

  • http://www.susritasen.blogspot.com Susrita

    At one point I do love the concept of Demo stores and also agree that point of sale at such stores will kill the very idea behind them.

    On the other hand the point raised by Hemant is also true. There might be a cause for a loss in potential customer.

    Now if Im not mistaken, I have spotted a similar demo store by Asian Paints where people casually walk in to check out their range, color, shades, feel etc. But yes I did see people taking down the contacts for Asian paints dealers. Now if the question is how to avoid a loss of potential opportunity, then maybe a followup may be carried on the potential leads. Also Nishant’s Idea is fabulous that a store should be located in the nearest proximity of the demo store.

  • Hemant

    @varun

    I agree with u on d above points, stil i feel there should not be incentives on sales as the concept of demo store does not promote this, else there wont be any difference between company showroom and demo store.

    For better lead management:
    if the customer is excited about our product then company can offer
    1. the list of authorised dealer in city with their contact nos.
    2. customer can place an order on phone to dealer and avail of home delivery service (as customer is fully aware of product and specification, no need to visit dealer)
    3. company can create a database of potential customers and update them on offers, schemes etc.

  • Varun

    @hemant: fair enough…but let’s take a step backward! Why does any organization exist? To make money…no two ways about it! How do they make money…by selling their products at a profit (I know now I sound stupid, but humor me). How do they achieve this? By creating a demand for their products and then supplying them through an efficient distribution system.
    Now let us look at objective for such a store.
    EXPERIENCE? Totally! High ticket item, commands more due diligence from a consumer point of view etc etc.
    CREATING BRAND EQUITY? Yes. But every marketing activity is eventually building your brand equity. Some more than others and in this case, experience is probably doing way better than others, simply because of the nature of the category.
    DIFFERENTIATING themselves from competitors? In all likelihood!
    AWARENESS? About the brand? I don’t think so. About the variety of cameras and lenses available? Maybe, but internet does a better job at that.
    But gaining all these intangibles to what end???
    BOOSTING SALES? Yes!Yes!Yes! It’s all connected and has to be!
    Now, if you have someone excited enough about your product, make the product available…and that is where you need to be careful.
    DO NOT KILL THE HEN WHICH LAYS THE GOLDEN EGG! Do not kill the concept which created that delta demand, just to serve that demand. At the same time, do not let go of this opportunity. Thus, as you rightly pointed out in your very first comment, need for a refinement to this concept of Demo stores.
    An efficient lead management system? I guess so!

  • Hemant

    @varun

    I feel that the organisation should decide the objective of opening demo store. if the objective is experience, awareness, creating brand equity and such intangible ones then they should not focus on giving incentives to saleperson on generating leads,as it is beyond the scope of objective.
    but if the indirect objective is boosting sales or creating demand for product then they should make available such product to customer before he changes mind to buy other one (ur example in preceeding comment) and also think about incentives to salesperson.

  • Varun

    @nishant: true! Left to their own devices, these salespeople will generate decent leads. But we were exploring the possibilities of making this a more structured process so as to minimize losing out on potential customers.
    On-demand delivery of a product from a store nearby does take away the “only experience” aura of the store. Moreover, logistically speaking, it might not be a feasible option. For example: I make up my mind to buy a product and the experience store orders it from the nearest store. While the product is on its way, I change my mind and decide to buy later and cancel the order…everyone ends up wasting time and effort for nothing!

  • Nishant Choudhury

    I feel we are overplaying the risks/disadvantages associated with the demonstrators notifying about leads.
    In the present arrangement, there is no incentive for them to perform anyways. But they still are doing a good job I suppose.
    Similarly, if we were to leave it on their judgement, they would surely create decent leads without any change in their approach to the guests…
    Another possibility could be ensuring that these lounges be opened in a 1 km radius of a Canon store and on-demand delivery of a product be done at the store….

  • Varun

    Heya! Back from a short and sweet vacation!

    @Shashank: thanks for the word of encouragement and filling in forme while I was away…and due credit where it belongs :)

    @Hemant: I guess Shashank has hit the nail on the head when he talks about “sales based incentives” taking the fun out of the whole experience…so better lead management is required!
    @Shashank: interesting idea, to link incentives to the successful conversion of leads…exploring this idea further

    1. Incentives based on no. of successful converts: They start listing down each and everyone as a potential lead, to increase their probability of making a convert, but resulting in unnecessary harassment for the customer
    2. Incentives based on percentage of successful converts: They list only a “very hot lead” as lead, again for obvious reasons and losing out on a lot of potential leads (though a much better system than what they have right now)
    3. Any other ideas??

  • Shashank Bajaj

    @Hemant

    if they start giving the option of spot buy, then again the devil of sale based incentives would creep in

    i believe the soln lies in better management of the leads that they get from these stores. they should note down the name & no. (only if the visitor is interested in buying) and then contact the person themselves… in fact even deliver it to his doorstep free of cost.

    this idea also gives a suggestion about incentive management for the demo store personnel. their incentive may be linked to the successful conversion of the leads received from these demo stores… just a thought starter

  • Hemant

    Hi,
    you explained consumer buying behavior well in short essay. the concept of Demo stores like Canon image store is still in its nascent stage in India. I will narrate my personal experience here. I visited canon image store in mumbai last yr(that time i didnt know that this is just a demo store) I was prompted to buy a digicam (impulsive buying). I could not buy it as it was just a demo store and I didnt buy afterwards since there was no canon shop in my locality.

    It was a potential customer loss for canon. If canon dealer/shop would have been in vicinity of such store then I could have probably bought one camera on d same day.

    I feel some refinement in concept of demo stores is needed in d form of either on the spot sale or future sale, they should not lose customer after spending huge money in building shop in superstore.
    What is your take on this??

  • Shashank Bajaj

    i took the pain of reading through the theory… and i lived to tell the tale :P

    thanks for attributing that creative bit to me :)

    on a serious note, a very good example considered to explain well a no. of marketing concepts in for understanding the purchase decision making process